Home
Indiana Best Lenders and Insurers

Author: Data Team

See the top-rated mortgage, loan, and insurance providers across Indiana's major cities, based on recommendations from local residents in MFP's Community Surveys.
Updated: September 29 2026
Bloomington Carmel Evansville Fishers Fort Wayne Hammond Indianapolis Lafayette Noblesville South Bend Online

Bloomington

The top-rated lenders and insurers in Bloomington, IN, based on recommendations from local residents in MFP's Community Surveys.
Best Home Mortgage
  1. BMO Harris Bank
  2. Fifth Third Bank
  3. Old National Bank
See full ranking →
Best Refinance
  1. First Financial Bank
  2. Old National Bank
  3. Peoples State Bank
See full ranking →
Best Auto Loan
  1. IU Credit Union
  2. Indiana Members Credit Union
  3. IAA Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Personal Loan
  1. IU Credit Union
  2. Everwise Credit Union
  3. Teachers Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Home Insurance
  1. Indiana Farm Bureau
  2. State Farm
  3. Erie Insurance
See full ranking →
Best Auto Insurance
  1. Cindy Vlasman, agent, State Farm
  2. Lisa Allen, agent, State Farm
  3. Rob Barber IV, agent, State Farm
See full ranking →

Carmel

The top-rated lenders and insurers in Carmel, IN, based on recommendations from local residents in MFP's Community Surveys.
Best Home Mortgage
  1. BMO Harris Bank
  2. Fifth Third Bank
  3. Lake City Bank
See full ranking →
Best Refinance
  1. Centier Bank
  2. Chase Home Lending
  3. PNC Bank
See full ranking →
Best Auto Loan
  1. FORUM Credit Union
  2. Indiana Members Credit Union
  3. Everwise Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Personal Loan
  1. FORUM Credit Union
  2. Indiana Members Credit Union
  3. Elements Financial
See full ranking →
Best Home Insurance
  1. Nationwide
  2. State Farm
  3. Allstate
See full ranking →
Best Auto Insurance
  1. Adam Jurs, agent, State Farm
  2. Andrew Kennedy, agent, State Farm
  3. Teresa Chapman, agent, State Farm
See full ranking →

Evansville

The top-rated lenders and insurers in Evansville, IN, based on recommendations from local residents in MFP's Community Surveys.
Best Home Mortgage
  1. Evansville Teachers Federal Credit Union
  2. Heritage Federal Credit Union
  3. German American Bank
See full ranking →
Best Refinance
  1. Mortgage Masters of Indiana
  2. Heritage United Mortgage Services
  3. First Bank
See full ranking →
Best Auto Loan
  1. Evansville Federal Credit Union
  2. Liberty Federal Credit Union
  3. Heritage Federal Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Personal Loan
  1. Liberty Federal Credit Union
  2. Heritage Federal Credit Union
  3. Teachers Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Home Insurance
  1. Indiana Farm Bureau
  2. Nationwide
  3. State Farm
See full ranking →
Best Auto Insurance
  1. Pam Lentz, agent, State Farm
  2. Chad Mabry, agent, State Farm
  3. Mary Rokicki, agent, State Farm
See full ranking →

Fishers

The top-rated lenders and insurers in Fishers, IN, based on recommendations from local residents in MFP's Community Surveys.
Best Home Mortgage
  1. Indiana Users Credit Union
  2. Fifth Third Bank
  3. First Merchants Bank
See full ranking →
Best Refinance
  1. First Merchants Bank
  2. PNC Bank
  3. First Internet Bank
See full ranking →
Best Auto Loan
  1. FORUM Credit Union
  2. Indiana Members Credit Union
  3. Everwise Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Personal Loan
  1. FORUM Credit Union
  2. Indiana Members Credit Union
  3. Everwise Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Home Insurance
  1. State Farm
  2. Allstate
  3. Indiana Farm Bureau
See full ranking →
Best Auto Insurance
  1. Clint Wilson, agent, State Farm
  2. Amy Henry, agent, State Farm
  3. WalkerHughes Insurance
See full ranking →

Fort Wayne

The top-rated lenders and insurers in Fort Wayne, IN, based on recommendations from local residents in MFP's Community Surveys.
Best Home Mortgage
  1. Fort Financial Credit Union
  2. STAR Financial Bank
  3. 3Rivers Federal Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Refinance
  1. Chase Home Lending
  2. PNC Bank
  3. Centier Bank
See full ranking →
Best Auto Loan
  1. 3Rivers Federal Credit Union
  2. Fort Financial Credit Union
  3. ProFed Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Personal Loan
  1. 3Rivers Federal Credit Union
  2. Partners 1st Federal Credit Union
  3. Everwise Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Home Insurance
  1. Erie Insurance
  2. Auto-Owners
  3. Indiana Farm Bureau
See full ranking →
Best Auto Insurance
  1. Ovation Insurance
  2. John Carr, agent, State Farm
  3. Shawn Corbett, agent, State Farm
See full ranking →

Hammond

The top-rated lenders and insurers in Hammond, IN, based on recommendations from local residents in MFP's Community Surveys.
Best Home Mortgage
  1. BMO Harris Bank
  2. Fifth Third Bank
  3. Old National Bank
See full ranking →
Best Refinance
  1. Centier Bank
  2. First Financial Bank
  3. PNC Bank
See full ranking →
Best Auto Loan
  1. REGIONAL Federal Credit Union
  2. FinAns Federal Credit Union
  3. Centier Bank
See full ranking →
Best Personal Loan
  1. Tech Credit Union
  2. Everwise Credit Union
  3. Teachers Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Home Insurance
  1. Allstate
  2. State Farm
  3. Farmers
See full ranking →
Best Auto Insurance
  1. Scott Angel, agent, State Farm
  2. Jesse Cervera, agent, State Farm
  3. Kyle Dempsey, agent, State Farm
See full ranking →

Indianapolis

The top-rated lenders and insurers in Indianapolis, IN, based on recommendations from local residents in MFP's Community Surveys.
Best Home Mortgage
  1. Elements Financial
  2. Forum Credit Union
  3. First Merchants Bank
See full ranking →
Best Refinance
  1. First Horizon Bank
  2. Chase Home Lending
  3. PNC Bank
See full ranking →
Best Auto Loan
  1. Indiana Members Credit Union
  2. FORUM Credit Union
  3. Financial Center First Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Personal Loan
  1. FORUM Credit Union
  2. Indiana Members Credit Union
  3. Elements Financial
See full ranking →
Best Home Insurance
  1. Hylant Group
  2. Gibson
  3. Nefouse & Associates
See full ranking →
Best Auto Insurance
  1. MJ Insurance
  2. Charlotte Adams-Jones, agent, State Farm
  3. Kyle Hale, agent, State Farm
See full ranking →

Lafayette

The top-rated lenders and insurers in Lafayette, IN, based on recommendations from local residents in MFP's Community Surveys.
Best Home Mortgage
  1. Purdue Federal Credit Union
  2. Fifth Third Bank
  3. BMO Harris Bank
See full ranking →
Best Refinance
  1. Centier Bank
  2. Chase Home Lending
  3. Old National Bank
See full ranking →
Best Auto Loan
  1. Purdue Federal Credit Union
  2. Industrial Federal Credit Union
  3. Staley Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Personal Loan
  1. Purdue Federal Credit Union
  2. Everwise Credit Union
  3. Teachers Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Home Insurance
  1. Indiana Farm Bureau
  2. Auto-Owners
  3. State Farm
See full ranking →
Best Auto Insurance
  1. Gina Kornafel, agent, State Farm
  2. Austin Kyle, agent, State Farm
  3. Jeff Onken, agent, State Farm
See full ranking →

Noblesville

The top-rated lenders and insurers in Noblesville, IN, based on recommendations from local residents in MFP's Community Surveys.
Best Home Mortgage
  1. BMO Harris Bank
  2. Fifth Third Bank
  3. Old National Bank
See full ranking →
Best Refinance
  1. First Farmers Bank & Trust
  2. Centier Bank
  3. Flagstar Bank
See full ranking →
Best Auto Loan
  1. FORUM Credit Union
  2. Indiana Members Credit Union
  3. Everwise Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Personal Loan
  1. FORUM Credit Union
  2. Indiana Members Credit Union
  3. Everwise Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Home Insurance
  1. State Farm
  2. Indiana Farm Bureau
  3. Erie Insurance
See full ranking →
Best Auto Insurance
  1. Angie Sutton, agent, State Farm
  2. Andrew Wolfe, agent, State Farm
  3. Ed Southard, agent, State Farm
See full ranking →

South Bend

The top-rated lenders and insurers in South Bend, IN, based on recommendations from local residents in MFP's Community Surveys.
Best Home Mortgage
  1. 1st Source Bank
  2. Teachers Credit Union
  3. Lake City Bank
See full ranking →
Best Refinance
  1. Centier Bank
  2. Chase Home Lending
  3. PNC Bank
See full ranking →
Best Auto Loan
  1. Notre Dame Federal Credit Union
  2. CommunityWide Federal Credit Union
  3. Everwise Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Personal Loan
  1. Everwise Credit Union
  2. Notre Dame Federal Credit Union
  3. Teachers Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Home Insurance
  1. Auto-Owners
  2. Erie Insurance
  3. Indiana Farm Bureau
See full ranking →
Best Auto Insurance
  1. Ron Donelson, agent, State Farm
  2. Tim Grauel, agent, State Farm
  3. Eric Guenther, agent, State Farm
See full ranking →

Best Online Lenders in Indiana

Top-rated online lenders serving Indiana residents statewide, based on recommendations from MFP's Community Surveys.
Best Home Mortgage
  1. Better Mortgage
  2. Rocket Mortgage
  3. Guaranteed Rate
See full ranking →
Best Refinance
  1. Rocket Mortgage
  2. Guaranteed Rate
  3. Better Mortgage
See full ranking →
Best Auto Loan
  1. Consumers Credit Union
  2. Alliant Credit Union
  3. Baxter Credit Union
See full ranking →
Best Personal Loan
  1. Indiana Members Credit Union
  2. Elements Financial
  3. FORUM Credit Union
See full ranking →